Comparisons
Comparisons
In home printing, the question of what is best almost always comes down to the question of what for. A hook for the hallway and a small decorative model with fine details call for different printing methods and different materials. In the tables below we compare not brands and models but the approaches themselves: that makes it easier to see what suits your tasks, your space and your habits.
The right printing method is the one you find comfortable to work with in your own home, not the one people talk about most.
How to read the tables: they describe general patterns. A particular printer or material may behave differently, so check its description and instructions.
Filament printing (FDM) vs resin printing
| Criterion | Filament printing (FDM) | Resin printing |
|---|---|---|
| How the part is built | The nozzle pushes out molten filament and lays it down layer by layer | Light hardens liquid resin in thin layers |
| Surface and detail | Layers are usually visible, fine details come out rougher | The surface is smooth, fine details come out sharper |
| Work after printing | Remove supports and sand if you like | Wash the part, post-cure it, and only then remove supports |
| Space requirements | A ventilated room and a stable table | Good ventilation, gloves, goggles and a place children and pets don't go |
PLA vs PETG vs resin (in general terms)
| Criterion | PLA | PETG | Photopolymer resin |
|---|---|---|---|
| Who it suits | Usually a beginner's first material | The next step when you need a tougher object | Those for whom fine detail matters |
| How it prints | Easily, without special demands on the printer | A little fussier, more prone to stringing between parts | Only on a resin printer |
| Strength and flexibility | Rigid but brittle on impact | Stronger and more flexible, copes better with loads | Depends on the type of resin, thin areas can be brittle |
| Heat resistance | Can deform in a hot place | Handles heat better | Properties vary widely, check the description |
| Handling | Keep dry | Keep dry | Work in gloves and goggles, store closed and in the dark |
Your own model vs a ready-made model from the web
| Criterion | Your own model | Ready-made model from the web |
|---|---|---|
| Fit for your task | Made exactly for your object and your measurements | May not match your object in size |
| Time and skills | You need to learn 3D modelling software | You can start printing almost immediately |
| Rights | You are the author and decide how the file is used | The author's licence applies and should be read in advance |
| What it teaches | Understanding how shape affects strength and printing | Seeing how experienced authors solve similar tasks |
How to choose without second-guessing
If you want to print household odds and ends and learn on simple parts, filament printing with PLA is a sensible starting point. If fine details and a smooth surface matter to you, look into resin printing, but think ahead about where you will work with resin and how you will ventilate the room.
Both methods grew out of long-standing inventions. Stereolithography, printing with light in liquid resin, was patented by Charles (Chuck) Hull, with the patent dated 1986; he is also credited with the STL file format. Fused filament printing was patented by Scott Crump in 1989.
Read also
- Guides
Step-by-step advice: preparing the file, first print, calibration, removing supports, useful things for the home. The article catalogue is here too.
- Tools
Bed scraper and brush, calipers, a dry box for filament, gloves and goggles, ventilation and a print log.
- Problems
First layer not sticking, stringing, layers separating, corners curling up, a clogged nozzle, a part that comes out the wrong size.
- Glossary
Slicer, layer, infill, supports, nozzle, first layer, post-processing and other home printing words in plain language.
- Questions
Answers about the guide, about printing and materials, about safety at home and about respecting the rights of model authors.
Sources
- Overview of the history of additive manufacturing (Wevolver)
- Printer and material manufacturers' instructions (in general terms)
This guide describes home printing in general terms and reflects the editors' view on the date it was prepared. Printers, filaments and resins all work differently, and menu items in model preparation software go by different names. If the instructions for your printer or material say otherwise, follow the instructions.